Find us on Google+

Thursday, 27 February 2014

Deficit woes, free falling Kwacha and more borrowing!

Parliament yesterday voted to increase the threshold of domestic borrowing payable over a period of ten years from K200m (US$35m) to K13 billion (US$2.3bn). Domestic threshold for loans repayable over one year has risen from K10m(US$5.8m) to K20bn (US$3.8bn). Finance Minister Alexander Chikwanda says the increase in the domestic borrowing threshold is meant to help the Patriotic Front (PF) government implement various economic projects given the burgeoning budget deficit and limited room for external borrowing.

Chikwanda's 2014 Budget has a huge hole that needs to be filled. The PF were looking to do that through a Eurobond before Christmas but the tapering of US credit has made it a little bit more costly for Zambia and other African economies to borrow. This has meant that PF has had to invent a Plan B. Though it is still possible that Eurobond may be revisited down the line if the situation improves.

The decision to increase domestic borrowing will inevitably crowd out private sector borrowing and make it difficult to bring down the cost of borrowing for ordinary Zambians. This is at a time when there’s already a legally binding maximum lending rate imposed by the PF. One suspects that the Budget 2014 will need to have more tax breaks for the Banks as a quid pro quo of some sort - as we saw last time.

That of course is the least of PF’s worries. The Kwacha this week broke the K5.80 per $1 barrier as it continues its free fall. For their part the Bank of Zambia continue to insist that the currency is simply on a "random walk"! And Mr Chikwanda insists “it's nothing to worry about”. They both know better than that, but what do we honestly expect them to say? 

The Kwacha has been falling for the last three years, but over the last four months it has lost substantial value (last month shown above) . It is currently the worst performing currency in Africa and there is every sign that this will continue. The Kwacha is losing against all major currencies. At the basic level this is expected because of the tapering of US credit. But there’s more happening.

The country faces significant structural, political and policy risks. Zambia public deficit continues to grow and it is very likely that this year it will miss the deficit target again. The 2014 Budget projected a 6.5% fiscal deficit target but this was predicted on high domestic revenues and measures to rein government spending, including wage freezes and limited FRA activities.

Based on spending policies alone the target was already not worth the paper it was written on. The IMF estimates that the fiscal deficit would come in at 7.4% at best. When the risk of non-tax revenues are priced in a fiscal deficit of around 8% plus seems very likely. That is before accounting for some of the already reversed hiring and wage freezes. In addition there non-budgeted spending commitments being made already (e.g. INDECO, new stadiums) which are all pointing to an even larger deficit.

On top of all this there’s the strong likelihood that government copper revenues are increasingly looking less favourable than assumed. Copper prices are headed for the longest slump in 20 years, on signs of weakening demand after manufacturing slowed in China and the U.S., the world’s top metals consumers. Copper in London has slumped over 15 percent in the past 12 months, partly as economic growth eased in China.

There's a huge risk that if the copper prices decline further Zambia's fiscal deficit will worsen because mining taxation revenues will be lower than forecast. Indeed, some believe this is part of the reason why Government has urgently moved to remove the debt limit for domestic borrowing. The problem is that with all these risks there’s a strong possibility of future credit downgrades. Indeed it seems some are already voting with their feet.

The sharply depreciation of the Kwacha now risks generating a spiral effect. Going forward we can expect Government debt repayments to become dearer. This may lead to further credit downgrades leading to much higher cost of future repayments. In general the cost of doing government business will become more expensive. On the production side the cost of imports are rising sharply, especially for mining companies where oil is a critical input for mining production costs.

On top of all this the Kwacha’s volatility brings its own challnges. With reserves currently low the central bank has little room to manage downward volatility . This further makes the Kwacha a riskier alternative for investors because it becomes inherently unpredictable. It is also a a problem for domestic businesses who may struggle with planning future decisions. There's also the important point that low reserves reduces confidence in Zambia's ability to service foreign loans. This is why dwindling foreign currency reserves are always associated with a deterioration in a country’s credit worthiness. 

All these problems are largely due to incompetence. We continue to see policy chaos at the heart of government. Unfortunately when you have a toxic cocktail of a politically captured central bank and incompetent fiscal managers one cannot ignore the politics that has created it. Economics does not exist in a vacuum.
Chola Mukanga | Economist 
Copyright © Zambian Economist 2013


  1. I hope the gvt does read this. This is eye opener, but with pride as this gvt is I doubt if thy can even try to change or improve on policies that are made. I wonder weather thy even hold meetings for consultations.

  2. Why to kwacha equivalent of $2,3 billion from $35 million. Why not admit the problems are serious but limit the borrowing to $200 million equivalent and slow down the projects for the greater good of stability.

    Is the effect inflationary also in two fronts. 1. This will result in monetary expansion i.e. printing extra kwacha. 2. A falling currency is usually inflationary also. In fact it is an uncontrollable embrace of economic death by these two factors which inevitably ends in price controls, shortages, parallel market, high prices etc.

    It seems this is back to the past with the same consequences of the past. But the blame will be placed squarely somewhere else and the politics of populism will ensure it will not be placed where it should be. Some people should not be put in charge of the cash box of a tuck shop. Far less than being put in charge of an economy.

    It is a tragedy in the making. The people like populism though so it will continue. All the promises of increase in wealth appeal and so are embraced even though they will result in increase in poverty.

    QE is being tapered further with the knock on effect on emerging market currencies. The time of QE benefitted emerging market economies but they did not prepare for its reduction which had been foretold by the USA. Hence the usual economic mismanagement manifests itself: take the benefit while it is there but don't prepare for the time when it will not be there.

  3. "Unfortunately when you have a toxic cocktail of a politically captured central bank and incompetent fiscal managers one cannot ignore the politics that has created it."
    I love it when educated Zambians write. Our command of the English language is second to none. Back to the point, through, unfortunately, Zambia is toast thanks to PF's economic illiteracy and economic mismanagement courtesy of the Toxic Triangle of a dictatorial President, an inept Finance Minister and a totally clueless Central Bank Governor. Sorry, Zambia. It's the crisis of the late 1980s through the 1990s all over again. Mwachuleni.


All contributors should follow the basic principles of a productive dialogue: communicate their perspective, ask, comment, respond,and share information and knowledge, but do all this with a positive approach.

This is a friendly website. However, if you feel compelled to comment 'anonymously', you are strongly encouraged to state your location / adopt a unique nick name so that other commentators/readers do not confuse your comments with other individuals also commenting anonymously.